HF vs SatCom for Emergency Use

HF vs SatCom for Emergency Use

When satellite communications came on the scene, there was much excitement about audio quality and security. However, the crippling costs of SatCom have delayed widespread adoption and implementation and given HF time to catch up. The latest generation of digital voice technology has effectively closed the gap between satellite and HF in regard to capability, making many emergency communications systems engineers reconsider SatCom and put their faith in dependable, cost-efficient HF once more.

Sound quality

The initial biggest benefit to SatCom was enhanced sound quality. HF had traditionally been plagued with excess static and distortion, making it less reliable. With digital voice over HF now available, near telephone quality audio that lacks the familiar background noise associated with old HF radio communications is achieved. Even inexperienced operators can hear and relay critical information. Vocoding has enabled HF voice quality to reach equivalency with satellite communications, and at 2,400 bps, the difference between the two methods of transmission is virtually indiscernible.

Communication security

Security was the other big selling point in the early days of SatCom, but with innovation comes ways to hack new systems, and satellite communications have proven vulnerable on various occasions. The majority of satellites are commercially owned, and are susceptible to jamming, eavesdropping, hijacking, anti-satellite weapons, electromagnetic pulses, cyber or infrastructure attacks and spoofing. By contrast, HF voice and data traffic is independent and offers various encryption and hopping options. Operators can freely discuss any operational matters without fear of breaching communications security.

Security was a major selling point in the early days of SatCom.

Locator services

HF can also provide safety compliance to locate and track deployed personnel operating in remote areas, independent of third-party infrastructure. Position reporting is readily achieved, and HF equipment can be used to interact with first responders, local or regional friendly forces and even international allies who have little or no SatCom capabilities. While SatCom devices can offer GPS, the usability depends on whether the service is accessible and online – and third-party infrastructure is a given, leaving the door open for security issues and signal dropout or dropoff.


Satellite phone service availability can be extremely volatile, with dead spots and dropouts causing loss of communication at what could be a critical moment. With no base or mobile stations as backup, an emergency can become much worse due to lack of transmission capability. Rugged terrain, foliage and unpredictable weather patterns can also inhibit satellite signals, causing intermittent connectivity or complete blocking.

HF can overcome difficult terrain issues with antenna systems that utilise near-vertical incidence skywave (NVIS) propagation for close communications even in mountainous or jungle terrain. HF radios with digital voice capability can deliver a working communications link even in the most challenging conditions or harsh environments, and can be combined with VHF for a communications network that has enhanced coverage for short- and long-range transmissions. Automated link establishment enables the radio to find the best signal path between stations, and switch as needed to keep signal strength steady and transmissions clear.


HF radio will often work easily with older equipment in remote or poverty-stricken locations, where newer equipment is hard or impossible to come by or may be stolen by insurgents. Satellite communication equipment can be much more difficult or even impossible to make backward-compatible, which can render it less helpful in situations where local communication is a critical part of an emergency response.


SatCom can be prohibitively expensive to maintain. The devices are costly, the networks require regular payment for data usage and communications can end up depending on third-party infrastructure that may be poorly maintained, inaccessible or even absent in remote areas. Conversely, HF may have a slightly higher original outlay, but has a longer life cycle, is forward- and backward-compatible and has no ongoing costs, since there are no subscription fees to utilise the equipment or use bandwidth.

Want to know more about modern HR capability? Contact the Barrett Communications team today.


The Hollywood Origins of Frequency Hopping

Frequency hopping is a method by which radio signals “hop” around a frequency in a pattern creating transmissions that are impossible to decipher from the outside. More Related News/Articles:How is HF radio used in 2020?3 basic elements of tactical HF radio securityWhat role does secure radio play in critical communication?Why security is the top requirement […]

How is HF radio used in 2020?

Some people seem to be operating under the misguided impression that high-frequency (HF) radio is nearing obsolescence, More Related News/Articles:How has HF radio stood the test of time as a…What’s the difference between how HF and VHF/UHF…Feeding The World: HF radio’s role in humanitarian…3 African communication challenges HF radio addresses

How is government communication – and communication technology – impacted during a pandemic?

The coronavirus pandemic has repeatedly illustrated the intimate interconnectedness of our global society. More Related News/Articles:Global pandemic: First steps in crisis communication techWhat we learned from the bushfires and how…HF Radio assisting disaster relief in PeruHF radio top tips for emergency communication during…

HF radio top tips for emergency communication during a disaster

Disaster preparedness is something that Australians have generally partaken in, especially after 11 September 2001, More Related News/Articles:How to effectively use HF radio communications in…Why HF radio needs to be part of your disaster planningWhy interoperability is crucial in HF critical communicationHF Radio assisting disaster relief in Peru

Global pandemic: First steps in crisis communication tech

The continuing progression of COVID-19 across the world underscores the need for robust and resilient communications technology. More Related News/Articles:How HF radio communication alleviate damage during wildfiresWhat we learned from the bushfires and how…How to set up HF radio for critical comms in infrastructureHow to increase your VHF radio capabilities

Connecting HF and VHF Networks

Radio communication can be accomplished across varying frequency ranges, but the working principles are different depending on whether you are using high-frequency (HF) or very high-frequency (VHF). More Related News/Articles:3 questions to answer when setting up a critical…What links line-of-sight to over-the-horizon…6 HF solutions essential for humanitarian agencies3 African communication challenges HF radio addresses

Post by onchada_admin